Introduction: A New Chapter in the Courtroom Saga
Criminal Justice Season 4 is back with yet another intense courtroom drama, this time titled “A Family Matter.” And let’s be real—if you’re a fan of slow-burning thrillers packed with emotional depth and legal mind games, this one might just win your heart. With the ever-brilliant Pankaj Tripathi reprising his role as the relatable, razor-sharp lawyer Madhav Mishra, the new season doesn’t just deliver a whodunit—it dives into complex relationships, mental health, and buried trauma.
So, what makes this season tick? Is it as gripping as the earlier ones? Let’s break it down—piece by piece.
The Plot: Love, Loss, and a Murder Mystery
The story kicks off with a grim discovery—Roshini Saluja (Asha Negi) is found dead in a blood-soaked mess, cradled in the arms of her lover, Dr. Raj Nagpal (Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub). Naturally, Raj becomes the prime suspect. But things aren’t so black and white.
Raj’s daughter Ira, a child with Asperger’s syndrome, was deeply attached to Roshini, who acted as her caregiver. Enter Raj’s estranged wife Anju (Surveen Chawla), who, against all odds, believes in his innocence. Desperate for justice, she turns to none other than Madhav Mishra, the common man’s lawyer with uncommon intuition.
Madhav Mishra Returns: Sharp Mind, Sharper Wit
Let’s face it—Criminal Justice Season 4 wouldn’t hit the mark without Pankaj Tripathi. His portrayal of Madhav is the glue that holds the series together. Equal parts brainy and empathetic, he walks into the courtroom like it’s his second home. With lines like “Hum wahi karenge jo humara kaam hai — defence,” he steals the show, effortlessly making even legal jargon feel charming.
And can we talk about his team? His rapport with assistants Barkha Singh and Aatm Prakash Mishra brings a splash of humour to the grim courtroom proceedings. Madhav’s wife, played by Khushboo Atre, also gets more screen time this season and delivers some much-needed comic relief while staying emotionally grounded.
An Emotional Web: Parenting, Pain, and Perspective
One of the most powerful undercurrents in Criminal Justice Season 4 is the emotional rollercoaster of parenting a neurodivergent child. Young Khushi Bhardwaj, playing Ira, is absolutely heart-wrenching in her role. While she doesn’t speak much, her presence is deeply felt.
Raj, meanwhile, is caught in a whirlwind of grief, regret, and overwhelming accusations. Mohammed Zeeshan Ayyub paints a complex picture of a man who’s broken but not beaten. His emotional restraint makes you wonder—did he do it, or is he just another victim of circumstance?
Anju’s Dilemma: Torn Between Love and Loyalty
Surveen Chawla, as Raj’s ex-wife Anju, is a revelation. She walks the tightrope between distrust and compassion like a pro. Her belief in Raj’s innocence isn’t blind—it’s born out of a deep, conflicted understanding of their shared past. Her restrained yet powerful performance gives the series some of its most compelling moments.
Supporting Cast: Heroes in the Background
The supporting cast brings a lot to the table. Asha Negi, despite a somewhat underwritten character, gives her best as Roshini. You can sense her love for Ira and her emotional struggle, but the character’s romantic arc with Raj feels a bit hurried—leaving the audience slightly underwhelmed.
Then we’ve got the legal heavyweights: Shweta Basu Prasad and Mita Vashisht, who bring fire and gravitas to the courtroom battles. The face-offs are less dramatic shouting matches and more like intense mental chess. And let’s not forget Kalyanee Mulay as the investigative officer—relentless, sharp, and unflinching in her pursuit of truth.
Direction & Storytelling: Subtle, Steady, and Sensible
Rohan Sippy takes a different route this season. He doesn’t go for flashy courtroom drama or melodramatic outbursts. Instead, he opts for subtlety, emotional nuance, and character-driven storytelling.
The narrative flows through two main tracks: the legal battle and the emotional dynamics of the family. Sometimes the pacing dips, especially in the middle episodes, but it’s forgivable because the emotional build-up pays off.
Themes Explored: More Than Just a Crime Story
What really makes Criminal Justice Season 4 stand out is its focus on real-life issues. From dealing with infidelity and mental health to the challenges of raising a child with special needs, the show isn’t afraid to tread complex waters. And guess what? It does so with maturity and respect.
The courtroom is not just a setting here—it’s a metaphorical battlefield where love, guilt, truth, and justice collide.
Strengths: Emotional Depth, Stellar Performances, and Realism
-
Pankaj Tripathi, obviously. The man can do no wrong.
-
Strong ensemble cast that holds their own.
-
Thoughtful exploration of neurodiversity and parenting.
-
A gripping story that feels rooted in reality.
-
Tense, well-written courtroom scenes.
Weaknesses: Uneven Pacing and Underdeveloped Arcs
-
Middle episodes drag a bit.
-
Roshini’s character arc could’ve used more depth.
-
Not as high on thrills compared to previous seasons.
Is It Worth Watching? Absolutely.
If you’re into courtroom dramas with emotional undertones, Criminal Justice Season 4 won’t disappoint. It may not be a fast-paced thriller, but it’s definitely a slow-cooked, emotion-heavy legal drama that gives you food for thought.
Read More: Inside India’s Civil Defence Mock Drill: How Operation Shield is Strengthening National
Conclusion
In a world of crime shows that focus on action, Criminal Justice Season 4 dares to pause, reflect, and explore the grey areas of morality, mental health, and relationships. It’s a gentle reminder that behind every legal case lies a tangled web of emotions—and sometimes, the law isn’t just about facts and evidence, but about understanding the human heart.
So, if you’re in the mood for something deeper, layered, and emotionally resonant, this one’s a solid pick. Just grab a cup of chai, settle in, and let Madhav Mishra take you on yet another ride through the complex corridors of truth and justice.
